New York City’s law says Rikers Island has to close by Aug. 31, 2027. Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s new plan, released Friday, says it will close by the end of 2032, more than five years late, according to amNewYork and The Associated Press.
The AP reported that the strategy “hinges on substantially reducing the number of people kept behind bars,” and said the city is all but certain to miss the 2027 legal deadline.
“We have a legal and moral obligation to close Rikers,” Mamdani said in a statement quoted by amNewYork. “Working alongside the City Council, Courts and nonprofit partners, we will meet it.”
The numbers
Under the plan, the first of four borough-based jails would open in Brooklyn in 2029, followed by the Bronx and Queens in 2031 and Manhattan in 2032, amNewYork reported. With three hospital-based therapeutic units, the new system would hold about 4,500 beds. Roughly 6,600 people are in city custody today.
To get there, City Hall wants the daily jail population at no more than 5,500 when Brooklyn opens and no more than 4,100 by the end of 2032. The plan lists $290 million in investments through fiscal 2030, including supervised release, alternatives to incarceration, reentry services and a doubling of electronic monitoring to 800 slots, amNewYork reported. The Guardian quoted Mamdani touting $146 million in support programs.
Asked what happens if the jail population is still too big for the new jails in 2032, the administration did not outline a contingency plan, according to amNewYork.
The critics
The New York Post editorial board, writing before the plan’s release, called it “mostly fantasy” and said it “barely begins to face reality.” The board argued the four borough jails add up to just 4,100 beds against about 6,650 inmates, that Rikers mostly holds people charged with violent crimes, and that the city should instead build modern jails on the island itself.
The city’s four elected district attorneys, Darcel Clark, Eric Gonzalez, Alvin Bragg and Melinda Katz, welcomed the effort but said in a joint statement that “we have a long way to go and many obstacles to overcome,” amNewYork reported.
City Hall said the City Council will introduce legislation to push back the legal deadline. Council Speaker Julie Menin said delays under previous administrations made it clear “more time is needed.”
What we know
- The plan sets the end of 2032 to close Rikers; city law currently requires Aug. 31, 2027.
- About 85% of people in city jails are held pretrial, according to the plan as reported by amNewYork.
- The city plans a task force with state courts to cut case delays, which it says could reduce the population by about 800 people.
What we don’t know
- Whether the City Council will pass a new deadline.
- What the city will do if the jail population stays above the new jails’ capacity.
- Whether the borough jails, already behind schedule, can open on this timeline.
Sources: The Associated Press, amNewYork, The Guardian, New York Post editorial board.
Follow First Feed News on Facebook for breaking news first.








Leave a Reply